· By Brandon Sample · Court decisions
Every case is different. A result in a past case doesn't necessarily mean success in another case.
On November 13, 2026, the Fourth Circuit affirmed the denial of Abdicasiis Cabaase's compassionate release motion. His mother was incapacitated, but his brother and his teenage daughter were already caring for her. That meant he was not her "only available caregiver" (United States v. Cabaase, No. 25-6241). Read the decision (PDF).
What happened
Mr. Cabaase appealed from the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, at Norfolk, where Senior District Judge Raymond A. Jackson presided. The criminal case is No. 2:10-cr-00057-RAJ-DEM-4. The Federal Public Defender's office represented him on appeal.
He asked the district court for compassionate release. That is a motion under 18 U.S.C. § 3582(c)(1)(A), which lets a federal judge reduce a prison term for "extraordinary and compelling reasons." Those are reasons that are unusual and serious enough to justify a change. The judge must also weigh the sentencing factors in 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a).
His reason was his mother's need for care. The Sentencing Commission's policy statement lists family circumstances that can qualify. One is "the incapacitation of the defendant's parent when the defendant would be the only available caregiver for the parent." That sentence is in U.S.S.G. § 1B1.13(b)(3)(C). Incapacitation, here, means the parent can no longer take care of herself.
The case was submitted on September 14, 2026, and decided on November 13. Judge King and Senior Judges Keenan and Floyd decided it without oral argument.
What the district court found
The opinion says the district court found that Mr. Cabaase's mother was incapacitated. So the first half of the test was met.
The second half was not. Two relatives were providing care to her: his brother and his teenage daughter. Because of that, the district court found he was not the only available caregiver.
Mr. Cabaase argued for a narrower reading of the word "available." As the opinion quotes his argument, the word "signals a lower bar to clear" because it carries limits on when a person counts as available. On that reading, he said, his brother and daughter were not available. The district court disagreed. It read "other available caregiver" to mean "other possible caregiver." Both relatives qualified, it said, because they were actively providing care.
The district court also decided, as a separate reason, that the § 3553(a) factors did not favor early release.
What the Fourth Circuit decided
The court of appeals affirmed, which means it left the denial in place.
The opinion notes that neither the Guidelines nor their commentary defines "only available caregiver." The court gave the words their plain, ordinary meaning. For "available," it borrowed a definition the Supreme Court used in Ross v. Blake, 578 U.S. 632, 642 (2016): "capable of use for the accomplishment of a purpose," and something that "is accessible or may be obtained."
Two relatives had been providing care. The court said that showed they were capable of taking part in that care. So the district court's finding that Mr. Cabaase was not the only available caregiver was not clearly erroneous. Clear error is a hard standard to meet on appeal. The appeals court does not redo the fact-finding. It asks only whether the finding was plainly wrong on the record.
Mr. Cabaase also pointed to his brother's leg injury. The court said the record "does not clearly establish" that the injury keeps his brother from providing adequate care.
The court stopped there. It said it did not need to "identify the exact contours" of § 1B1.13(b)(3)(C) to affirm. It did not set a full test for when a relative counts as available.
On the § 3553(a) factors, the opinion says the district court discussed the nature and circumstances of the offense, proportionality with other sentences, the time already served, and Mr. Cabaase's conduct since sentencing. A district court does not have to address every argument one by one. The reasoning given was enough.
The decision is unpublished. The slip opinion states that unpublished opinions are not binding precedent in this circuit.
What this means for a motion
- The person asking for release has to prove the caregiver point. The opinion says it is the defendant's burden to show he would be the only available caregiver.
- Relatives who are already helping count against the claim. In this case, a brother and a teenage daughter who were giving care were treated as available.
- A relative's own health limits need records. The brother's leg injury did not change the result because the record did not clearly show it kept him from giving adequate care. The opinion does not say what proof would have been enough.
- The § 3553(a) factors are a separate hurdle. The district court relied on them as a second reason, and the appeals court upheld that too.
- The opinion leaves questions open. It does not decide whether a relative who lives far away, works full time, or is a minor is always available. It decides only that this finding, on this record, was not clearly wrong.
Family circumstances are collected on the eligibility page. The process guide walks through the warden request and the motion in the sentencing court. Our post on United States v. Graham covers another recent Fourth Circuit parent-care appeal.
If you want us to review how these rules might apply to a federal case, Request a consultation.
Source: United States v. Cabaase, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, 25-6241. Read the court document