Originally published March 15, 2021. Statements about the law were updated in October 2026; the box below gives today’s rules.

Update (October 2026): the law has changed. This post was first written in 2021, when some courts let people use compassionate release to challenge very long sentences. In Rutherford v. United States, 608 U.S. 454 (2026) (decided May 28, 2026), the Supreme Court held that a sentencing change Congress did not make retroactive cannot be an “extraordinary and compelling” reason, alone or combined with other reasons. The article below was rewritten to state the current rule.

Usually not. Since May 28, 2026, the fact that a sentence would be shorter under today’s law cannot be an “extraordinary and compelling” reason for compassionate release when Congress did not make the change retroactive (Rutherford v. United States, 608 U.S. 454 (2026)). That rules out motions built on § 924(c) “stacking” and similar changes. A federal judge can still shorten a sentence for reasons tied to the person’s own situation: serious illness, age, a family emergency, abuse in custody, or other reasons just as serious.

What compassionate release is

Compassionate release is a request asking the federal judge who imposed a prison sentence to make it shorter. Under 18 U.S.C. § 3582(c)(1)(A), the judge can do that only if “extraordinary and compelling reasons” warrant it, the reduction is consistent with the Sentencing Commission’s policy statement (U.S.S.G. § 1B1.13), and the sentencing factors in 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a) support it. The Supreme Court has described “extraordinary and compelling” reasons as reasons that are especially unusual and convincing.

Since the First Step Act of 2018, the person in prison can file the motion. First, they ask the warden in writing. They can go to court 30 days after the warden receives the request, or sooner if they finish the Bureau of Prisons’ appeals.

What § 1B1.13(b)(6) says

In 2023, the Sentencing Commission added a ground called “unusually long sentence,” now U.S.S.G. § 1B1.13(b)(6). It says that if a person received an unusually long sentence and has served at least 10 years, a change in the law (other than a Guidelines amendment that was not made retroactive) may be considered, but only if the change would produce a gross disparity (a very large gap) between the sentence being served and the sentence likely to be imposed when the motion is filed, and only after full consideration of the person’s individual circumstances.

A related rule, § 1B1.13(c), says that apart from (b)(6), a change in the law cannot be used to decide whether an extraordinary and compelling reason exists. It adds that once a person shows such a reason on other grounds, a change in the law may be considered in deciding how much to reduce the sentence.

What Rutherford left of it

Very little that helps. In Rutherford, the Supreme Court held that the gap created by a sentencing change Congress did not make retroactive cannot be an extraordinary and compelling reason. In the Court’s words, Congress’s nonretroactive change to § 924(c), “considered by itself or in combination with other factors—cannot make a prisoner eligible for compassionate release.” The Court held the Commission’s policy statement invalid “to the extent” it says otherwise. That is the main use (b)(6) was written for.

The Court also explained that compassionate release has long centered on a person’s own circumstances, like medical condition, age, and family circumstances. And it said that treating the severity of a mandatory sentence as a reason for compassionate release would reject Congress’s judgment that the punishment fits the crime.

The Court did not rewrite (b)(6) word for word, and it said it did not need to decide whether some other kinds of later developments could ever qualify. As of November 2026, the Sentencing Commission has not changed (b)(6) or (c). The guideline amendments that took effect November 1, 2026 changed only wording in other parts of § 1B1.13 (“Bureau of Prisons” becomes “Federal Bureau of Prisons”). Rutherford also did not decide how the last sentence of § 1B1.13(c), about the size of a reduction, works now. If you or someone you love is relying on a long sentence as the reason for a motion, have the theory checked against Rutherford first.

Stacked § 924(c) sentences and other changes that were not made retroactive

Before the First Step Act, a second § 924(c) gun conviction in the same case carried a mandatory 25-year sentence that had to run after the first one (it was “stacked”). The First Step Act ended that for people who had not yet been sentenced. It did not reach people already sentenced.

From 2020 to 2023, federal appeals courts split on whether that gap could support compassionate release. Some allowed it in combination with other factors, such as the Fourth Circuit in United States v. McCoy, 981 F.3d 271 (4th Cir. 2020). Others did not, such as the Third Circuit in United States v. Andrews, 12 F.4th 255 (3d Cir. 2021). Rutherford settled the question: arguments based on non-retroactive changes, including § 924(c) stacking, no longer support a motion, even when combined with other reasons. The same holding covers other sentencing changes Congress did not make retroactive.

When this post was first written in 2021, some district courts granted motions on this theory (for example, United States v. Urkevich, 2020 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 197408 (D. Neb.)). Those decisions are history, not today’s law.

What still counts

The grounds in U.S.S.G. § 1B1.13(b) that are tied to the person’s own situation still apply:

  • Medical circumstances: a terminal illness; a serious condition or impairment that badly limits self-care in prison and will not improve; a condition that needs long-term or specialized care the prison is not providing; or a disease outbreak or public health emergency that puts the person at higher risk.
  • Age: 65 or older, a serious decline in health because of aging, and at least 10 years or 75 percent of the sentence served, whichever is less.
  • Family circumstances: the caregiver of the person’s minor child (or of an adult child who cannot care for themselves) has died or is incapacitated, or a spouse, registered partner, or parent is incapacitated and the person would be the only available caregiver, or a similar situation with another close family member.
  • Abuse in custody: sexual abuse, or physical abuse causing serious bodily injury, by a correctional officer or other person with custody or control, while serving the sentence.
  • Other reasons: other circumstances, alone or together with the ones above, that are similar in gravity.

Good conduct and programs in prison can help a motion, but rehabilitation alone is not an extraordinary and compelling reason (28 U.S.C. § 994(t); U.S.S.G. § 1B1.13(d)). For the full rules, see who qualifies for compassionate release and federal compassionate release.

If the real argument is that the conviction itself is wrong, that belongs in a motion under 28 U.S.C. § 2255, not in a compassionate release motion (Fernandez v. United States, 608 U.S. 411 (2026)).

How to start

The first step is a written request to the warden that explains the extraordinary and compelling reasons and gives a release plan. Thirty days after the warden receives it, a motion can be filed in court under 18 U.S.C. § 3582(c)(1)(A), even if the warden has not answered. See how the process works.

If you want help with a compassionate release request, Request a consultation.